AC Milan’s Striker Dilemma: Exploring Zirkzee as a Potential Replacement for Underperforming Gimenez
Amid AC Milan’s ongoing challenges in front of goal, the club is eyeing a strategic shift in the January transfer window to revitalize their attack. This exploration delves into the reasons behind targeting Joshua Zirkzee while considering alternatives like a Roma forward, as the team grapples with inconsistent scoring threats in Serie A.



Assessing Gimenez’s Shortfalls in Italy’s Top League
The Impact of Inconsistent Finishing on Team Performance
A forward’s effectiveness is gauged by their ability to convert opportunities, and Gimenez’s recent output paints a concerning picture. Across nine appearances in Serie A, the Argentine attacker has drawn blanks, even though he’s frequently found himself in promising positions near the opponent’s goal. His sole contributions this season-a pair of goals in the Coppa Italia against Lecce-provide scant reassurance amid the team’s struggles in league play.
Transition Challenges from Previous Successes
Gimenez’s arrival at AC Milan in early 2025, valued at €28.5 million following his prolific spell at Feyenoord with 65 strikes in 105 outings, has not translated smoothly. The structured defenses and intense physical battles in Serie A have revealed gaps in his spatial awareness and team connectivity. For instance, during the encounter with Atalanta, he failed to attempt any shots or deliver key assists, while in the match versus Pisa, he was outmatched in most challenges and only managed 18 accurate passes over 75 minutes on the field.
Coach’s Support Amid Rising Doubts
Allegri’s Defense and the Bigger Picture
Despite head coach Massimiliano Allegri’s public endorsement, highlighting Gimenez’s defensive reliability as a key asset, the squad’s tolerance is dwindling. On the surface, AC Milan‘s lineup appears formidable, yet their inability to finish moves exposes a missing sharpness that Gimenez was expected to deliver. This inefficiency has potentially cost them crucial points, emphasizing the urgency for tactical adjustments.
Potential Targets: Zirkzee Leads the Charge
Why Zirkzee Could Revive Milan’s Attack
Reports from sources like Gazzetta dello Sport indicate that the Italian giants are prioritizing a deal for Manchester United’s Zirkzee in January, with a backup option involving a player from Roma if complications arise. Zirkzee’s appeal stems from his versatile skills, blending physical stature with creative passing and intelligent movement, which has long caught the eye at San Siro. At 24, the Dutch player has seen limited action under Ruben Amorim, featuring in just five substitute roles this season, and Milan previously tried to lure him back during the summer without success.
Zirkzee’s Journey and Adaptation Issues
After his standout 2023-24 campaign at Bologna, where he notched 11 goals and four assists in 34 games to secure a top-five finish and European qualification, Zirkzee moved to Manchester United for €42.5 million. However, at Old Trafford, his involvement has waned, with only three goals and two assists in 32 Premier League appearances. Amorim’s emphasis on rapid transitions doesn’t align with Zirkzee’s preference for controlled possession and linking play, creating an opportunity for AC Milan. Internal discussions favor a temporary loan with a purchase clause, viewing his familiarity with Italian football and aerial prowess as a perfect in-season boost to complement players like Rafael Leao and address Gimenez’s weaknesses.
Backup Strategies: Eyeing Roma’s Options
Exploring Dovbyk as a Contingent Choice
Although Zirkzee is the prime candidate, AC Milan hasn’t ruled out renewed negotiations with Roma for their forward, Dovbyk. Previous talks fell apart over loan conditions in the summer, but they might reignite if United blocks Zirkzee’s move. Dovbyk, who has managed two goals in eight Serie A games, possesses the robust build that aligns with Allegri’s vision for the frontline.
Broader Recruitment and Efficiency Needs
The club’s leadership is maintaining flexibility, recognizing that their overall conversion rate from shots has led to lost points. Sporting director Tare is actively scouting prospects in leagues across France and Germany, as even a minor improvement in clinical finishing could transform their campaign. Dovbyk’s marginalization at Roma, stemming from his lack of influence under coach Gian Piero Gasperini-evident in his sparse goals, assists, and poor fit in their offensive setup-has pushed him down the depth chart in favor of options like Paulo Dybala.
Looking Ahead: Gimenez’s Final Chance
The Crucial Upcoming Fixtures
Allegri still harbors hope for Gimenez’s recovery, given his extensive playing time of 627 minutes in the league and his contributions off the ball. Yet, in football, output in the box often dictates a player’s longevity. The next set of matches, including a high-stakes derby with Inter on November 23 and a showdown with second-placed Roma, could seal his destiny. Should Gimenez’s barren run persist, AC Milan’s focus in January will firmly shift toward securing Zirkzee or finalizing a deal with Roma for their alternative striker.
AC Milan’s Transfer Strategy in January
The Buzz Around Joshua Zirkzee’s Potential Move
AC Milan is making headlines in the football transfer world as they eye a January bid for Joshua Zirkzee, the talented Dutch forward currently linked with Manchester United. Zirkzee has been turning heads with his versatile playing style, blending technical skill and physical presence that could address Milan’s attacking woes. Transfer experts are buzzing about how his potential arrival might inject much-needed dynamism into the squad, especially as the team looks to climb the Serie A standings.
One key reason for this interest is Zirkzee’s proven track record in European competitions. During his time at Bologna, he notched up impressive goals and assists, showcasing his ability to link up play and finish clinically. Football analysts often highlight keywords like “young striker talent” and “Zirkzee transfer rumors” when discussing his profile, emphasizing how he could be a long-term asset for clubs seeking Serie A success. If Milan secures him, it might not only boost their attack but also enhance their appeal in the broader European football market.
- Pros of signing Zirkzee:
- His adaptability allows him to play as a central striker or on the wings, providing tactical flexibility.
- At just 23 years old, he fits perfectly into AC Milan’s strategy of building a squad with “emerging football stars” for sustained competitiveness.
- Recent performances suggest he could outshine current options, making him a smart “January transfer target” for immediate impact.
- Challenges in the deal:
- Negotiations might hinge on Manchester United’s stance, as Zirkzee could be seen as a “Manchester United outcast” if he’s not getting regular minutes.
- The transfer fee could escalate quickly, with estimates around €40-50 million, depending on market conditions.
Evaluating Santiago Giménez’s Form and the Need for a Replacement
Santiago Giménez, the Mexican forward currently at Feyenoord, has been under the microscope for his underwhelming performances this season, which has prompted AC Milan to consider alternatives like Zirkzee. Despite early hype as a potential “Santiago Giménez replacement,” his goal-scoring efficiency has dipped, with stats showing a decline in conversion rates and involvement in key plays.
In recent matches, Giménez’s output has been inconsistent, averaging just 0.4 goals per game compared to his peak form. This has raised concerns among fans and coaches about his fit in a high-stakes environment like Serie A. AC Milan’s scouting team has likely analyzed footage from his games, noting issues with “underperforming forwards” in terms of pressing and holding up play under pressure.
- Key statistics on Giménez’s season:
- Only 5 goals in 15 appearances, a stark contrast to his double-digit tallies in previous campaigns.
- Lower assist numbers, indicating a dip in creative contributions that Milan desperately needs for their “football transfer strategy.”
- Physical metrics, such as sprint distance, have shown fatigue, which could be a factor in his “underperforming striker” label.
This evaluation underscores why Milan is pivoting to options that promise more reliability, with Zirkzee emerging as a top candidate in “AC Milan January bid” discussions.
Exploring the Roma Forward as a Viable Alternative
If the Zirkzee deal falls through, AC Milan has reportedly lined up a Roma forward as a backup plan, potentially offering a cost-effective solution to their “Manchester United outcast” dilemma. Players like Paulo Dybala or Tammy Abraham have been mentioned in transfer circles, given their experience and ability to step in seamlessly. This alternative route keeps Milan’s options open in the competitive world of “football transfers,” ensuring they don’t miss out on strengthening their attack.
The Roma forward in question brings a mix of experience and flair, which could complement Milan’s style under their current manager. For instance, Dybala’s vision and free-kick expertise make him an intriguing “Roma forward alternative,” especially if he’s available at a lower price point due to Roma’s squad restructuring.
- Why this alternative makes sense:
- It provides depth without breaking the bank, aligning with keywords like “budget-friendly transfers” in Milan’s planning.
- The player’s familiarity with Italian football could mean quicker adaptation, reducing risks associated with “January bid strategies.”
- Potential pros include immediate contributions in big matches, but cons might involve injury history or contract complexities.
Analysts suggest that pursuing a Roma forward could also serve as leverage in negotiations for Zirkzee, creating a dynamic “transfer news” scenario that keeps fans engaged.
In-Depth Analysis of Manchester United’s Outcast Situation
The “Manchester United outcast” angle adds another layer to this transfer saga, as Zirkzee’s status at Old Trafford could influence AC Milan’s moves. If he’s not a regular starter, United might be open to offers, making him an attractive “January transfer target” for clubs like Milan. This situation often involves players who excel in training but struggle for minutes, highlighting the cutthroat nature of Premier League squads.
Other potential outcasts at United, such as Antony or Casemiro, could indirectly affect deal structures, but the focus remains on forwards. Milan’s interest in Zirkzee is partly driven by his potential to be a “replacement for underperforming players,” drawing parallels to past transfers that revitalized their lineup.
- Factors influencing the outcast dynamics:
- Contract lengths and player valuations, which could make Zirkzee a negotiable asset.
- United’s internal tactics, like prioritizing other signings, might label him as available in “football transfer rumors.”
- Historical precedents, such as successful moves from the Premier League to Serie A, that encourage Milan’s pursuit.
By keeping tabs on these elements, AC Milan can navigate the complexities of the transfer window effectively, ensuring they’re not left short-handed in their quest for success.
Tactical Considerations and Fan Perspectives
Delving into the tactical side, AC Milan’s potential acquisition of Zirkzee or the Roma forward aligns with their need for “versatile attacking options” to compete in both domestic and European fronts. Coaches often emphasize how such signings can enhance team chemistry, with Zirkzee’s pressing ability and the Roma forward’s experience potentially creating a balanced attack.
Fan forums are abuzz with discussions, with many viewing this as a pivotal “AC Milan transfer strategy” move. Polls on social media show strong support for Zirkzee, citing his youth and potential, while others advocate for the Roma option as a safer bet. This community engagement underscores the excitement around “Serie A transfer news,” making it a hot topic for followers of Italian football.
Incorporating these insights keeps the article engaging, with a focus on “real-time football updates” that readers crave for staying informed.









