Toney recently suggested that his Al-Ahli side would “finish close to the top four” if they played in the Premier League. Ronaldo has also backed the idea that Saudi Arabia’s top flight is on par with Europe’s elite leagues. Brady, however, has dismissed those views, pointing out weak attendances and the age profile of many imported stars.
“Ivan Toney’s claim that the Saudi Pro League is on a par with the Premier League left me gobsmacked,” Brady wrote in her article with The Sun. “Footballers have every right to ply their trade where they want. But to put Saudi’s nascent project — going since 2008 — alongside the world’s gold standard in football isn’t just a stretch, it’s nonsense.”
She added: “The Saudi Pro League just isn’t widely watched, even in Saudi Arabia. Last term’s average gate was 8,354 with our League One at 10,102 and League Two 6,090. With huge investment, the Saudi Pro League will perhaps one day reach a competitive standard worth genuine respect. But it won’t for a long time be on a par with the Prem.”
The Saudi Pro League has made waves by attracting marquee names like Ronaldo, Karim Benzema, and Sadio Mane with massive contracts. Yet, many of these players are in the twilight of their careers, and the league’s popularity remains limited, even locally. Brady argues that while Saudi investment is undeniable, it cannot yet rival the Premier League’s global reach, packed stadiums, and competitive balance.
Toney and Ronaldo’s comments will continue to stir debate about Saudi Arabia’s football project and its rapid growth. Premier League figures, however, remain confident their competition is unmatched in quality and commercial appeal. For now, Saudi football still has a long road to travel before being viewed as a genuine equal to England‘s top flight.
