'Realistic opportunity to make a World Cup' – While Shaka Hislop has concerns over Patrick Agyemang's Derby County transfer, Herculez Gomez praises USMNT striker's move

Hislop and Gomez offered contrasting perspectives on the American striker's recent transfer to the Championship side

USMNT Rising Star’s Leap: Agyemang’s Derby County Gamble Sparks Debate

In the evolving landscape of American soccer talent, Patrick Agyemang’s switch from ل County in the English has ignited discussions among experts. This $8 million transfer not only highlights Agyemang‘s growing profile but also underscores the USMNT‘s depth in forwards as the 2026 approaches. With the Championship offering a tougher proving ground than MLS, this move could propel the striker toward international stardom or expose areas needing refinement.

  • Hislop concerned about Derby Championship struggles
  • Gomez ranks Agyemang among top five USMNT strikers
  • Championship represents development step above MLS

'Realistic opportunity to make a World Cup' - While Shaka Hislop has concerns over Patrick Agyemang's Derby County transfer, Herculez Gomez praises USMNT striker's move'Realistic opportunity to make a World Cup' - While Shaka Hislop has concerns over Patrick Agyemang's Derby County transfer, Herculez Gomez praises USMNT striker's move'Realistic opportunity to make a World Cup' - While Shaka Hislop has concerns over Patrick Agyemang's Derby County transfer, Herculez Gomez praises USMNT striker's move

Shaka Hislop’s Reservations on Agyemang’s Derby County Shift

Following Patrick Agyemang’s departure from Charlotte FC to join Derby County, expert Shaka Hislop voiced doubts about the timing, pointing to the team’s vulnerable standing in the league as a potential hurdle for an emerging talent.

Weighing the Risks of Derby’s Mid-Table Battles

“I’m somewhat hesitant, mainly due to the situation at Derby County,” Hislop remarked during a Futbol Americas episode. “With Agyemang, his strengths are clear-cut-he’s a robust forward who excels at retaining possession. Yet, like many in his position, he could refine his precision in front of goal. Despite his solid contributions, he lacks that killer instinct inside the penalty area.”

“But this chance arises-and his stats from Charlotte, along with his showings for the US men’s team, back that up. Landing at Derby, a side that’s hovering in the mid-tier and barely avoided the drop last term, adds an element of uncertainty.”

Matching Style with Derby’s Gritty Approach

Hislop noted that Agyemang’s attributes align well with Derby’s no-nonsense strategy, though improvements in specific skills are essential.

“You can predict their style,” Hislop continued. “They’ll be tough, disruptive, and rely heavily on dead-ball situations. Agyemang fits right in as a powerful, combative forward who must embrace a more rugged edge-far beyond what he’s displayed in the USMNT setup so far.”

“Plus, sharpening his goal-scoring edge is crucial. On paper, his profile suits Derby’s tactics, but delivering consistent output will be key to steering the club away from relegation threats, much like their narrow escape in the previous campaign.”

Herculez Gomez’s Enthusiasm for Agyemang’s Championship Venture

In contrast, Herculez Gomez expressed strong approval for the transition, viewing it as a smart progression for the USMNT hopeful.

A Promising Path from Underdog to Contender

“I see this as an excellent step into the Championship,” Gomez stated. “Patrick Agyemang stays authentic to his game, and his career arc is logical. This is someone who’s beaten the odds-from Division III college ball to breaking into MLS, overcoming early setbacks, and earning national team call-ups, even in lesser tournaments, where he started finding the net.”

“He’s the type who toughed it out with a hernia during the Gold Cup, when others opted out, still posing problems despite reduced agility… It’s an ideal environment for him to polish his abilities and grasp the demands of higher-level play.”

Elevating Beyond MLS Toward World Cup Aspirations

The ex-USMNT forward highlighted how the Championship surpasses MLS in intensity, positioning Agyemang favorably for a spot in the 2026 World Cup squad, especially with recent inconsistencies among top strikers-evidenced by the USMNT’s mixed results in 2024 qualifiers, where goal droughts plagued the frontline.

” Is he the definitive No. 9 for the USMNT at this moment? No way,” Gomez admitted. “Top three? Unlikely. But in the fourth or fifth position? Definitely. Given the underperformance of the leading options lately, that gives him a genuine shot at the World Cup roster.”

“By seizing this platform, advancing in a demanding league, and honing his edge, he stands as good a chance as any forward to secure that international berth.”

Agyemang’s Challenge: Solidifying at Derby Amid Relegation Pressures

Agyemang departed MLS for Derby County in an $8 million deal that benefited Charlotte FC significantly. Now, he faces the task of cementing his role while boosting the team’s attack, all while Derby navigates survival worries in the lead-up to the 2026 World Cup, where updated FIFA rankings show the USMNT climbing to 11th globally, heightening competition for spots.