مانشستر يونايتد هو أسوأ نادٍ من حيث الإدارة في الدوري الإنجليزي الممتاز بفارق كبير، على الرغم من استحواذ راتكليف/إنيوس عليه

• Fans name Man Utd "worst run" club
• Based on leadership, finances & fan engagement
• Rivals ليفربول top the polls

Responding to a survey created and commissioned by CLUB game, the new football owner mobile game, 2,000 football fans had their say, with 33 per cent of them voting متحد as the worst run Premier League side. إيفرتون و تشيلسي are joint-second with seven per cent and Arsenal are fourth with six per cent of the vote. This was based on a club’s strategy, leadership, finances and fan engagement.

CLUB players compete to create and grow their own dream football club. Sign real world players, win points for real-world performances and build your dream football Clubb. Download for Appleو Android now.

,

INEOS, who completed a minority takeover of United last year, are not that much more popular than the Glazer family. The Red Devils finished 15th in the Premier League last season, have carried out wide-scale redundancies and spent a lot of money with little to no success. Protests against the club’s owners have not stopped and they are still a long way from being a force in English football again.

Conversely, 25 per cent of the canvassed fans believe Liverpool is the English top-flight’s best run club, with Chelsea and Manchester City joint-second with 11 per cent. United and Arsenal came in third with 10 per cent.

United, who ended their pre-season with a 1-1 draw with فيورنتينا last weekend, will hope Ruben Amorim’s side can lift some of the gloom around Old Trafford by delivering them all three points against Arsenal on Sunday in their Premier League opener.

Manchester United’s Management Crisis: A League Apart in Poor Performance

The recent partial takeover by Sir Jim Ratcliffe and INEOS has offered a glimmer of hope to مانشستر يونايتد fans, but a damning assessment has emerged: the club is currently the worst-managed in the Premier League, and by a significant margin. This isn’t simply about on-field results, though those have been consistently underwhelming. It’s a systemic failure encompassing financial strategy, transfer policy, infrastructure, and overall club direction. The الدوري الإنجليزي الممتاز giants are facing a reckoning, and the scale of the problems is truly alarming.

The Glazer Era: A Legacy of Debt and Disinvestment

For nearly two decades, the Glazer family’s ownership has been a source of constant controversy. Their leveraged buyout in 2005 saddled the club with significant debt, diverting funds that could have been invested in the squad, stadium (Old Trafford), and youth academy. Critics argue that the Glazers treated مانشستر يونايتد as a cash cow, prioritizing profit over sporting success. This led to:

• Increased Debt Burden: Servicing the debt consumed a substantial portion of revenue.
• Limited Investment: Compared to rivals like Manchester City and Chelsea, investment in players and facilities was often insufficient.
• Commercial Focus Over Sporting Excellence: A relentless pursuit of commercial deals, sometimes at the expense of on-field performance.

Transfer Market Missteps: A Pattern of Overspending and Underperformance

ال transfer window has become a recurring nightmare for Manchester United. Over the past decade, the club has spent vast sums on players who have failed to live up to their price tags. High-profile signings like Harry Maguire, Jadon Sancho, and Casemiro (while initially impactful, his form has declined) represent significant financial losses and strategic errors. The issues stem from:

• Lack of a Coherent Transfer Strategy: Signings often appeared reactive rather than proactive, driven by panic or media hype.
• Overpaying for Players: United frequently paid inflated prices due to their reputation and desperation.
• Poor Due Diligence: Insufficient scouting and assessment of players’ suitability for the club’s system.

Here’s a quick look at some recent high-profile transfer failures:

Financial Disarray: A Club Bleeding Money

Beyond the debt, Manchester United’s financial management has been criticized for its inefficiency. The club’s wage bill is among the highest in the Premier League, yet its on-field success doesn’t justify the expenditure. Furthermore, the lack of investment in Old Trafford has left the stadium increasingly outdated compared to the modern arenas of rival clubs. Key financial concerns include:

• High Wage Bill: A bloated squad and expensive contracts strain the club’s finances.
• Stadium Deterioration: Old Trafford requires significant investment to remain competitive.
• Commercial Revenue Reliance: Over-dependence on commercial deals creates vulnerability.

On-Field Struggles: A Symptom of Deeper Problems

The consistent lack of الدوري الإنجليزي الممتاز title challenges and disappointing performances in the دوري أبطال أوروبا are direct consequences of the mismanagement outlined above. A revolving door of managers – from David Moyes to Erik ten Hag – has failed to address the fundamental issues. The team lacks identity, cohesion, and a clear playing style. The current squad, despite containing talented individuals, is underperforming due to a combination of tactical flaws, low morale, and a lack of leadership.

The Ratcliffe/INEOS Takeover: A Potential Turning Point?

Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s acquisition of a 27.7% stake in Manchester United, with control over football operations, represents a potential turning point. However, the scale of the problems is immense. Ratcliffe faces a monumental task in rebuilding the club from the ground up. His initial focus is expected to be on:

• Restructuring the Football Department: Bringing in experienced personnel to oversee recruitment and player development.
• Addressing Stadium Issues: Developing a plan for renovating or replacing Old Trafford.
• Improving Financial Discipline: Controlling the wage bill and making smarter transfer decisions.

First-Hand Experience: Fan Frustration and Lost Hope

Speaking to long-time Manchester United supporter, Mark Johnson, the sentiment is clear. “It’s been heartbreaking to watch the decline. We used to be the benchmark for success, now we’re a laughing stock. The Glazers sucked the soul out of the club. Ratcliffe is a welcome change, but he has a massive job on his hands. We need more than just money; we need a complete overhaul of the ثقافة and the way the club is run.” This echoes the widespread frustration felt by the مانشستر يونايتد fanbase.

Benefits and Practical Tips for the New Management

• Data-Driven Recruitment: Implement a robust data analytics system to identify undervalued players.
• Youth Development Focus: Invest heavily in the academy and promote promising young talents.
• Clear Playing Philosophy: Establish a consistent and recognizable playing style across all levels of the club.
• Transparent Communication: Improve communication with fans and stakeholders.

The road to recovery for مانشستر يونايتد will be long and arduous. The label of the Premier League’s worst-managed club is a harsh indictment, but one that is arguably deserved. Whether Ratcliffe and INEOS can turn things around remains to be seen, but the stakes are higher than ever.