'He should retire now' – Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues

The veteran striker has scored just three goals in 34 appearances since returning to Chivas

Chicharito Hernández Faces Growing Calls to Retire Amid Performance Slump and Controversies

In the ever-evolving world of Mexican football, Javier ‘Chicharito’ Hernández’s return to Chivas has sparked intense debate. Once hailed as a hero, the striker’s recent struggles on and off the pitch have led experts to question if it’s time for him to hang up his boots, preserving his storied legacy before it fades further.

  • This marks his fourth year back with the team
  • He missed the opening game versus León
  • Reports suggest his deal won’t see an extension

'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues'He should retire now' - Mexican media criticize Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández for poor form and off-field issues

Escalating Backlash Over Chicharito Hernández’s Recent Scandals and Form Dip

The storm of criticism directed at Javier ‘Chicharito’ Hernández has intensified following his controversial gender-related comments, compounding the negative feedback he’s received since rejoining his formative club, Chivas, after thriving in European leagues and the MLS. This comeback phase has largely underperformed, with a mere three goals across 34 appearances, compounded by limited opportunities under successive managers coaching the now 37-year-old forward.

A Legacy at Risk: From National Icon to Under Scrutiny

مثل ‘s top goal-scorer in history and a standout figure among Mexicans in European football, Hernández has long enjoyed considerable admiration. However, his subpar showings combined with the latest external drama-resulting in penalties from both Chivas and the Mexican Football Federation-have prompted voices to suggest he bow out gracefully.

Expert Opinions: Time for Chicharito Hernández to Step Down?

Prominent among the detractors is Ricardo ‘Tuca’ Ferretti, a legend with seven titles and current ESPN commentator, who delivered a straightforward verdict: “It’s best for him to call it quits immediately-exit the sport on his terms, rather than being pushed out.”

“I anticipated a strong campaign for him, given the full preseason preparation,” Ferretti continued. “Yet, an early operation, followed by another setback, and a warm-up injury have all compounded the challenges.”

Preserving a Storied Career: Ferretti’s Advice on Retirement

Ferretti advises against extending Hernández’s contract post-Apertura 2025, emphasizing the need to safeguard his reputation: “Given the persistent injuries and his present circumstances, retirement seems wise. Fans cherish his exploits at clubs like Manchester , , , and with Mexico. We shouldn’t let that fade into obscurity.”

Insights from Former Players: Parallels and Recommendations

During a FOX Sports segment, ex-forward Carlos Hermosillo noted that Hernández doesn’t align with coach Milito’s tactics anymore, likening it to his own exit: “I stepped away when I realized my contributions were waning-I refused to linger as a substitute.”

Eduardo de la Torre shared his experience of contemplating retirement at age 31 due to bodily wear and tear, encouraging Chicharito to follow suit: “Opportunities should now go to emerging talents.”

Chicharito Hernández’s Contract Uncertainty and Injury Woes at Chivas

Reports from FOX Sports Mexico indicate that Chivas has no intentions of extending an offer to Hernández upon his contract’s expiration this season. Presently, he’s nursing a calf strain from his most recent outing and remains doubtful for the upcoming fixture, contingent on his participation in team sessions.

A Timeline of Setbacks: From ACL Tear to Ongoing Struggles

Hernández rejoined Chivas hampered by an ACL rupture sustained in the MLS, which postponed his Liga MX return. Subsequent ailments include an ankle problem, various muscle pulls, a knee twist, and additional injuries that have hampered his output.

Into 2025, fresh complications like another ankle concern, a face injury, persistent calf troubles, and further muscular issues have persisted. Consequently, his tally stands at only three goals in 34 outings.

Financial and Team Context: High Stakes for Chicharito Hernández

At Chivas, Mexico’s record international goal-scorer commands a yearly wage of $2.5 million. Recent updates show that as of mid-2025, his goal drought continues, with no additions to his tally amid a reported dip in Liga MX striker productivity league-wide, where top scorers average just 1.2 goals per game this season.

The Guadalajara-based squad is set to face Atlético de San at home on Saturday for Matchday 3, amid ongoing discussions about squad rotations and veteran roles.